Thursday, September 12, 2013

The Paradox of Declining Female Happiness


This study: The Paradox of Declining Female Happiness was published in 2009 by the American Economic Journal, and it shows how women's happiness has decreased in the last four decades.
These results are surprising if we think about all the social changes and better opportunities that women have achieved in the last 40 years. All these improvements would make us believe that women's welfare should have increased.
In this paper, some of the causes for this “unhappiness” are formulated. One is that the increased opportunities for women outside the household might have brought more work and responsibilities to women's lives. They also suggest that men are the ones who have really benefit from women's liberation movements. “...with the expansion of opportunities have come costs, and that men may have been the beneficiaries of the women’s movement. In particular, many sociologists have argued that women’s increased opportunities for market work have led to an increase in the total amount of work that women do.”
“Sexual freedom offered by the birth control pill may have benefited men by increasing the pressure on women to have sex outside of marriage and reducing their bargaining power over a shotgun marriage in the face
of an unwanted pregnancy.” They also suggest that inequality between men and women still exist, even though women have achieved benefits in many areas, men are still in a privilege position over women. “Did men garner a disproportionate share of the benefits of the women’s movement? Alternatively, perhaps the well-being data point to differential impacts of social changes on men and women, with women being particularly hurt by declines in family life, rises in inequality, or reductions in social cohesion.”

This makes me wonder if the real issue is that there's still a lot of work to do from feminist movements to eliminate institutional and social inequality between men and women or if maybe Suzanne Venker and Phyllis Schlafly, in their book: The Flipside of Feminism: What Conservative Women Know and Men Can't, are right when they say: “Feminism has sabotaged women's happiness. To be truly empowered, women must reject feminism.” 




2 comments:

  1. In regards to the Paradox of Declining Female Happiness I agree with your questioning of the explanations given. While I disagree with the majority of the video I see logic in the idea that men are not the enemy. While humans are not perfect I think that for forward movement we must allow men to be part of the solution.

    My personal beliefs aside both present persuasive arguments that are particularly impactful when viewed together.

    ReplyDelete
  2. That there has been a drastic decline in the happiness of women in America in a paradoxical correlation with the happiness of men in the last 35 years is certainly startling, and understandably offers the anti-feminist camp its most valid and potent point of criticism in their crusade. However, Venker and Schlafly seem to have a very narrow if not limited scope, perhaps even a flagrant and offensive disregard, for the benefits that have been wrought by the 2nd Wave on an international scale. "The Paradox for Declining Female Happiness" also states that "Many of the legislative gains for women have been shown to increase women's subjective well-being. For example, Pezzini (2005) demonstrates that within Europe, women's life satisfaction increased with the introduction of birth control and abortion rights and several studies have demonstrated an association between more education and higher subjective well-being." Worth noting here is that because the number of women holding advanced degrees has increased so drastically in the 35 year period of analysis presented here the data is quite new and varies greatly from the same statistical education levels corresponding to male self-satisfaction.

    All told, while I am disappointed in what appears to be an increased lack of fulfillment and happiness for women, it does seem a bit too early to be so highly critical of the movement and its gains. This decrease in the happiness of American women could very much be the product of the half-hearted implementation of legislation regarding gender equality. That is to say, the increasing cultural acceptance of the right of women to work and to operate on the same plane as men in other arenas without the associated benefits which exist in other countries where this decrease is significantly smaller or nonexistent, ie Universal Daycare, Health Benefits, etc. The workload placed on the shoulders of American women has definitely drastically increased, and this could well be the source of increasing frustrations, but I personally place fault in the hands of American policy, as any gains that have been made seem to be offered up only with the concession that women may strive for equality in the professional world only so long as they continue to simultaneously work to maintain the order and balance that is the microcosm of their respective households.

    ReplyDelete