This post is partially inspired by a recent trip I made to Sephora, the makeup store with a friend of mine. Generally, I think people assume that I'm gay, and that I "perform homosexuality, or queerness." Contrasting to me, is my friend who identifies as a woman of color and is usually recognized as so. What we experienced in the store, and other outlets of consumerism is that I was being provided with an excessive amount of customer service and even praise (to the point of being offered sample products), while my friend was only approached once, only to be lightly criticized for how she did her makeup. I bring attention to these videos, because I wanted to lightly poke at this upcoming phenomenon of men being able to occupy traditionally separate "performances" of gender at the same time, and in certain subcultures, can do so without the negative consequences usually associated with "breaking your gender role." Though the typical assumption is that most of these men are homosexual, I'm not quite sure if sexuality is as relevant anymore when discussing the luxury to having the choice to "multitask" traditional gender roles, though perhaps the idea that these men being homosexual allow the idea to be more feasible to certain people. Regardless, I feel like there can be an argument made that, "gender-breaking" acts are becoming much more acceptable to a man, than they are to women, even in places such as New York City. Also, This is further instigated by factors of race, and perceptions of social class.
I'm a makeup artist, and I was speaking to one of my mentors who is an established gay makeup artist here in NYC- and he told me that there is extreme admiration for gay men who are makeup artists because it is something that they have to work hard to do and had to deal with large amount of societal pressures and stigma, whereas women are familiarized and taught about makeup from a young age so they already have the upper-hand when it comes to progressing into a career with that knowledge.
ReplyDeleteThis insight was something I had never thought of before, but it makes sense to me now and I think it is something that society in general is starting to accept is that gay men have had to work very hard to get past something and so we should applaud them for their hard work and dedication.
I think that the lesbian movement is a lot 'younger' in that it has been less talked about and less in the spotlight than gay men. So I think society has not completely accepted and/or glamourized lesbians yet to the degree that they do with men (as you see in the above videos.)
Both Hoi and Alyssa make excellent points here but I want to challenge you both to think through these issues in relation not only to race and class but also to male privilege, which can both work to both benefit men ( as we see with male make-up artists and hairstylists) and against them (as we see with the incredibly high rates of discrimination and violence toward male-to-female transgendered folks).
ReplyDelete