Miley Cyrus has been called-out recently for her obvious appropriation of black culture in her new reinvention of herself. In her music video 'We Can't Stop' she uses black women as her backup dancers and therefore Miley is put in the forefront and the black women are pushed to the background.
"In the pop culture circus, the white woman is the ringleader and the women who look like you are the dancing elephants."
The problem is not that the black women are in the background per se, but that they are meant to foreground Miley's 'white sexuality' and the control she has over them. Her performance is meant to be for the male gaze where men can fantasize about their white women dominating over other (more exotic) black women. And it's also worth noting that the black women that Miley dances with do not look like the often-celebrated Rihanna, Halle Berry, or Beyonce- instead they are large, curvy women w/ exaggerated assets that are hyper-'black', hyper-sexualized, and meant to be exotic-looking in an almost barbaric way.
"That is how black round female bodies become inferior. That is the inferiority Cyrus is ostensibly rooting against in “We Can’t Stop” when she encourages “homegirls with big butts” to reject the “haters” because “somebody loves [them].” Just who is that somebody is left unanswered, but I suspect it isn’t the white male audience for whom Cyrus performs her faux bisexual performance. That is choreographed for the white male gaze against a backdrop of dark, fat black female bodies and slightly more normative café au lait slim bodies because the juxtaposition of her sexuality with theirs is meant to highlight Cyrus’ supremacy, not challenge it. Consider it the racialized pop culture version of a bride insisting that all of her bridesmaids be hideously clothed on her wedding day."
Miley has defended that the black women used in her music video are her 'homies' and that they hang out together. Miley has also said other remarks that it's the 21st century and all different kinds of people are getting together and collaborating and that hip-hop music is universally loved and celebrated around the world- so she doesn't see a problem with working with black people.
I find her defensive argument similar to the popular saying- 'I'm not racist- I have a black friend!'. In the politically correct world that we live in, do we constantly have to be careful of what we project to the world all the time? Or is it enough to understand that you yourself are not racist, and you have black friends that enjoy working and collaborating with you- and everyone else needs to deal with it and you can't make everyone happy?
http://www.slate.com/articles/double_x/doublex/2013/08/miley_cyrus_vma_performance_white_appropriation_of_black_bodies.2.html
Alyssa Martin

Alyssa raises some very good questions about how we might interpret Miley Cyrus's use of urban black culture, asking if it is appropriation or collaboration. But I want to add another question to the mix: does Miley Cyrus represent the death of feminism or the next step in its evolution? In other words, do you view her self-presentation as being an act of feminist defiance (I can do whatever I want) or as the manufactured product of a patriarchal and misogynistic media?
ReplyDelete