“The Problem That Has Two Names”
By Pamela Paul
The New York Times// Aug. 24, 2013
This
article reminded me of broader ideas of femininity that seem to consistently
include the expectation of sacrifice. Though marriage today may have in many
ways developed past its original purpose of the transfer of property, many
traditions we keep remind us of the assumed superior status of the husband and
paternal lineage. While the wife is traditionally expected to give up a symbol
of her family history in order to unite the family under a common name, an
equal sacrifice is not expected of the husband.
I
find it interesting that only now, when it poses a logistical problem for a
woman wishing to lead a consistent identity in the workplace as well as a
family life, that it is discussed and questioned. I understand the appeal of
symbolically merging the family, but feel it is important to make the effort to
recognize the woman as an individual before she is referred to only in terms of
her relationship to a man.
While
combining a couple’s last name using hyphenation may be a nice compromise for
one generation, I think it may become too burdensome to repeat in the next
generation (for the sake of name length) let alone set this as the new
standard. I’m not sure there is a
solution to this problem, besides calling for a relaxing of social codes that
may restrict couples from seeing all of the possibilities-including a husband
adapting his wife’s last name as his own.
A few questions I have: Is
tradition that was built in times of inequality/discrimination ever appropriate
to hold on to? What does it mean when marriage traditions rooted in gender
inequality stay with a society that strives to improve?
I thought this article was very interesting because it always seemed weird to me that women in the US had to change their names when they get married. In my country (Spain) it's never been like that. All women keep their last names and when they have children, they have two last names: the father's last-name and the mother's last-name and that's the family name: the union of both last names. I agree with you that when a woman gives up her last name is making a sacrifice and for me is a symbol of submission and loosing identity. I think that in the current society this is an obsolete tradition that causes confusion and supports institutional inequality. When a woman gives up her name is imply that the man is the patriarch and the head of the family. This way of thinking is what feminism has tried to eradicate from the system, which is a patriarchal system, and doesn't make sense to continue reproducing sexist patterns. There might still exist sexism and discrimination over women at the individual level (which we can't control) but nowadays sexism shouldn't exist at least at the institutional level. How are we going to eliminate inequality and sexist patterns in society if children grow up seeing this kind of inequality embedded in tradition and institutions (like the institution of marriage)?
ReplyDeleteThis article is very interesting, as this issue of women giving up their last name after marriage is an unjust practice going on for decades. Her last name has always defined her and is a part of her identity. Taking that away means taking away a part of her. This is an obsolete tradition, which is being scrutinized by the current generation. Women of our generation do not want to leave their family name after marriage as by taking away their names it’s like taking away their identity. By giving her last name she not only gives in to the patriarchal society but also shows her dependency on her husband. Though there hasn’t yet been a solution to this problem, as each solution seems to have many drawbacks.
ReplyDeleteI've always felt that a woman giving up her last name was an unfair practice, as the man never has to. I'd certainly never want to and the hyphenation would be terrible with my last name, since it's two words already. If women hyphenate to keep their last names, why don't men hyphenate to add the women's last name too ? It's also interesting to think that women have the titles Ms and Mrs, in order to differentiate between a single woman or a married woman, and yet men only have Mr. Just another related thought.
ReplyDeleteI've always felt that a woman giving up her last name was an unfair practice, as the man never has to. I'd certainly never want to and the hyphenation would be terrible with my last name, since it's two words already. If women hyphenate to keep their last names, why don't men hyphenate to add the women's last name too ? It's also interesting to think that women have the titles Ms and Mrs, in order to differentiate between a single woman or a married woman, and yet men only have Mr. Just another related thought.
ReplyDelete