Friday, September 27, 2013

Death Sentences in Sexual Attack Case in India




Many Doubt Death Sentences Will Stem India Sexual Attacks

NYTimes / September 13, 2013
By Ellen Barry and Betwa Sharma


I found the topic of this article interesting in its acknowledgement that the threat of punishment, no matter how extreme, may not be enough to change culturally conditioned behavior. Although the number of registered rape and molestation cases rose dramatically while the government began creating a fast-track court for rape cases, introducing new laws to protect women and allowing certain rape cases to constitute capital crimes after the brutal gang rape in Delhi, it is clear that violent crimes against women are still occurring in large numbers.

It is important when looking at this type of crime to recognize its disconnect from the assumed pursuit of sexual desires and fulfillment and acknowledge its purpose of obtaining power and control. Men, who are often very close to their victims, are committing acts that are firstly used as a means of acquiring dominance. The Delhi rape that sparked this nation and worldwide conversation involved the violent penetration of the victim with a metal bar leading to extensive internal injuries and making it clear this act can not be attributed to uncontrollable sexual desire but instead was an attack designed to inflict pain. Noting the fact that most sexual violence against women is perpetrated by someone that the victim knows, as the article points out, emphasizes the prevalence of this type of disturbed perception of women not only in strangers, but in the men that they know and trust as well.  

While many may find peace in knowing that individuals who commit these types of crimes are punished severely, it may only amount to the elimination of identified rapists rather than a widespread change in the perception of women’s worth by men in today’s world. A culture that views women as individuals deserving of this type of treatment is not easily changed.

As punishment is one of the most common ways governments attempt to dissuade people from committing crimes, I wonder if there are other more effective ways in which change can be brought about on a major scale. Maybe education is the best way to begin to rid our world of the aspects and attitudes that make it an unsafe environment in which to be born female. Working to eliminate the institutionalized sexism present in our world may be one of the most important steps to protect women’s physical safety as well. 

1 comment:

  1. This is an example of how sexism is embedded in society, of course in some cultures more than in others. In India, they still have a lot to do towards women's rights and equality, but I agree with the article that revenge is not the way to achieve it. Although I believe some "punishment" is necessary because every action has a consequence but it shouldn't be a way of seeking revenge because violence only generates more violence and that way doesn't lead to any real change. Real change comes from addressing issues from the root and try to solve what is causing them. Otherwise it's just like putting patches, the problem will go on reproducing or even making it bigger. "[...] some of India’s most ardent women’s rights advocates hung back from Friday’s celebration, skeptical that four hangings would do anything to stem violence against women"
    Karuna Nundy is right when she says: “I think a lot of people were hugging each other because they thought this evil is localized, and it will be wiped out, and that is not the case." This problem has deeper roots. India is a very gendered country mainly ruled by men, and women don't feel any support from the institutions. There is still a huge institutionalized inequality supported by their traditions and religion. Also the insecurity on the streets is due to poverty conditions and a very stratified society where social policies are almost inexistent. The safety of a country is very influenced by its economic stability. If people had a better quality of life, good jobs, wages and support from the state, there would be more happy people, therefore less people willing to harm others so less criminality.
    http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/worldviews/wp/2012/12/29/india-rape-victim-dies-sexual-violence-proble/

    ReplyDelete