Friday, September 13, 2013

8 Reasons NOT to Send Your Daughter to College.

http://www.fixthefamily.com/blog/6-reasons-to-not-send-your-daughter-to-college

"Actually, since the purpose of a college degree is for a job, it becomes unnecessary for our daughters to have such a credential.  My personal impression is that the day-to-day grind of a job is below the dignity of women...The feminist world has twisted this so that a job (career) appears elevated, and homemaking is denigrated.  This is the evil work of Satan and devastating to families."
"Is a degree worth the loss of your daughter’s purity, dignity, and soul?"

This article was written by Raylan Alleman of the website Fix the Family, which is aimed at people about conservative Catholic family life. It is interesting that this article is written by a man aiming at telling people to keep their daughters (and not sons) from going to college and getting an education. The main point of this article is that he thinks women shouldn't need a degree because they don't need jobs, as their primary purpose is to have children and be mothers - "Sending our wives out to work should be a very last resort, a misfortune, so it shouldn’t be part of a plan for young ladies before they even get a start at family life.  Keeping a home, being a loving wife, and being a nurturing mother are of immeasurable dignity to a woman and not something to be farmed out to servants."

It is interesting that Alleman's main point is about the family and women's main purpose being mothers. There is no point in which he mentions the daughter's choices about whether or not they want to go to college and have a job or become a mother. In one point of the article he seems to put women on a pedestal, saying that jobs are "below the dignity of women" and yet at another point he says that "Christian marriage by definition does place her in a submissive role to her husband". Which one is it? Are women too good for jobs or are they supposed to be submissive to their husbands? 

I am so perplexed by this article. It is crazy that a man in 2013 can think that women do not need a higher education because they do not need it to be mothers. How can a man think that feminism is evil and destroying families in our society? 



3 comments:

  1. After reading through this article there is one point which I do not agree with. Which is, "She will not learn to be a wife and mother." The reason for my disagreement is because I believe that as humans, we will always find a way to adapt to our surroundings. Even if it was not taught to us, we will find a way to learn. Therefore, if we do not learn to be a wife and mother in school, we will find a way to learn it through trail and errors. Then again, how do you teach someone to be a good mother in school? They say, experience is the best teacher.

    -Tina

    ReplyDelete
  2. This entire article is very saddening. By the tone that it is written in, it sounds like the author wrote this to scare young women and make them ashamed for ever wanting something more in life.

    "Educating and caring for children is the most valuable calling of a married woman and requires accomplished abilities. These are no small matters. But mothers often say they could not stand to be with their children all day. What? Just stop and think about that sad sad statement. If that is the case, why did they have children? In choosing for our daughters, we may need to bring them to awareness of this attitude and direct them toward the single life or to that of a religious sister."

    It's shocking to see that the author makes it sounds like you have a choice to have children or not. In most conservative religious groups the women HAVE children. Your husband will expect you to (or force you to), and if you don't you will be shut-out and singled-out. It is not socially acceptable to not have children. And he tries to guilt women for 'not wanting to be with their children all day' by basically stating that you are heartless if you ever feel that way and should have stayed celibate.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree with Alyssa, that this article seems to have been written to scare or threaten young women into wanting anything besides a life of motherhood.

    I also find it puzzling that there is an assumption that going off to college, and being independent, does not teach one the skills of running a home/having children. Couldn't the opposite be argued? That going to school and living on your own exposes you to all of the things you need to be prepared to do (cook, clean, organize your time) these chores? Isn't it also true that you cannot really learn how to have a child until you have a child, meaning that there's no way to prepare, so why avoid going to school in the meantime?

    There just seems to be a lot of flaws and assumptions in this argument...

    ReplyDelete