Wednesday, October 9, 2013

I thought a lot about the conversation about intent--whether Miley Cyrus's intent makes a difference in whether she is a figure of feminism or not--in response to Barthe's "Death of the Author." I definitely agree that, in some regards, her intent does not matter: she has become a figure head who is seen and all that matters is what she puts out there, not necessarily the meaning, intent, or idea behind it. Her authorship is irrelevant when all the world sees is her 'product' (performances, music videos, public appearances, public image via social media, etc.). However, at the same time, I can't help but think of what happened to, for example, Chic-Fil-A. They said they did not support gay lifestyles and thousands of people boycotted the company (this is a complex issue, but speaking in generalities). Isn't this a reaction from the public based on the intent of the company? Chic-Fil-A's statements did not change their product--as Miley's 'product' does not change, regardless of her intentions--but people still chose to no longer consume that product because of what it stood for. Countless other examples come to mind, such as the firing of John Galliano for his anti-semetic remarks and the boycott of Visa credit cards after their sponsorship with the Russian Olympic games and the anti-gay sentiment that was projected from the hosting country. While they are all very different and unique situations, I can't help but wonder if people could include Miley's intent in part of their analysis of her celebrity; if people could, as they have with other situations, bring intention into the conversation, as something to be judged alongside, in contrast with, or in acknowledged spite of, her 'product.'

As Chelsea pointed out to me, this thought process raises very important questions about the bodies of pop stars: are their bodies commodified in the same way that other products (Chic-Fil-A, for argument's sake) are? ... Should they be?

I'm not sure I necessarily think that they should be. I don't really feel comfortable even referring to people as "bodies" (which seems to be the language used when discussing such things... ie: many articles  referred to Miley's back up dancers at the VMAs as "black bodies" juxtaposed with her "white body"). This said, I feel that the media feeds pop stars to me as objects. It is almost as if they are packaged and sold based on their performances, music videos, and public appearances--they are branded by the media and then marketed towards that brand. So, if we don't know if we support the brand, why do we buy the brand? Why do we not change the channel when her performance comes on, or avoid viewing the music videos that are intended to shock (and are judged based on the numbers of clicks and views they receive)? Is it important to know what is going on (to be a part of contemporary conversation, to know who is doing what and why), if doing that validates a message we may not agree with?

Back to the question about pop stars' bodies... Are they the same as chicken wings? I'm not sure. But I think we do have a choice to either buy into or opt out of the marketing; and, not actively opting out, is--in this technological framework--interpreted as support.

1 comment:

  1. I do agree that we should be more aware of our "choice" to support or not support these brands, but I don't know if intent should necessarily be considered too much because it is so often used as a way to justify an action that is wrong regardless.

    Intention is strange, because you often have to go back to identify what qualifies as "intention." I would argue that most of the racist, homophobic, genocidal actions that people support are not results of a direct "intention" to be racist, homophobic or genocidal. If some one is homophobic as dictated by the perceived beliefs of their religion, as preached by their local priest, it's hard to say whether their intentions are to be homophobic, loyal to their church, or to sustain the ideals of their belief system. Most of the time, these actions are encouraged by existing social relations and desires. Because of this, it is much more effectively to consider the reality of what happened, rather than the person's "intent" because it's prone to a ridiculous level of subjection, and it's ultimate irrelevance to the actual repercussions of the person's actions. I do think it's important to consider intent to consider why people do the things they do, since perhaps if Miley was more aware of her own intentions, this whole thing would have never happened.

    There is also difference with Chic-Fil-A, and boycott of products, and the critique of commentary based on the performance of people. Mainly because, as you stated, the items that Chic-Fil-A, and the olympic games do not directly have anything to do with the issues being talked about.

    Galliano's, and Cyrus' controversies is directly about their performance being representative of something racist.

    In this way, the reaction of boycott is about the company's political aflliation, rather than the product, and the reaction to Miley is about her product.

    ReplyDelete