http://www.hulu.com/watch/542172
Weeks after Miley Cyrus's VMA performance she is still all the talk. While some may label her another Britney (Spears) or Lindsay (Lohan) I struggle to categorize her as a female celebrity who spiraled out of control.
Her performance on SNL (October 5) proved to me that this 20 year old is smarter than many want to believe. I planned on writing this post exclusively on her parody music video, We Did Stop, however every segment of SNL Cryus appeared on was just as well executed. Throughout her performance she constantly addressed gender roles and the double bind placed on women. She was able to laugh at herself but also stood her ground.
With a segment based on Hillary Clinton the discussion of "doing it for the women" is explicitly addressed. Another scene I found particularly interesting was set in a classroom. The performance opens and immediately the male teacher exits the room claiming to have gotten a real job (Apparently, teaching is not considered a real job.) and the replacement teacher, a female poet, takes over the class. The students perform various poems describing drugs as well as slut shaming. Then the nerdy female teacher recites a Haiku that clearly describes oral sex. However, due to the nature of the work and the performers awkward physical attributes this is deemed poetry and perfectly appropriate for a classroom setting.
So why did Miley's VMA performance outrage so many people? She wasn't sending a message we hadn't hear before. Barely clothed performers and black girls twerking is nothing we haven't seen before. I cannot help but think that society is only comfortable with male performers confronting their sexuality and exploiting female bodies. Would this performance have gone uncontested had Miley allowed her male counterpart to domesticate her? Just as the teacher's physical appearance made her poetry acceptable, unfortunately a male body would have made Miley's performance acceptable.
I acknowledge that the SNL cast and whomever is handling Miley also deserves credit.
On another note... I think it's really interesting (and important) to note the dimensionality of Miley's approach to her celebrity (at least in the current moment). She is engaged in this push/pull (from her music videos and VMA performance to her SNL skits and MTV documentary--in which she acknowledged some of the outrageous things she did, saying they were done exclusively to promote record sales). What is perhaps most interesting (maybe even more than what she actually does) is always the public's response. People freak out and bombard social media when they're mad at her, then post statements arguing that she "really can sing" when they see something like her SNL performances. Yet, no one seems to discuss what all of this could do to a very public, very high profile young woman (she's not even 21 yet...). Regardless of my opinion on what she is doing (which I think many of us can all agree on), I do feel there should be an awareness of what happens when you come forward and harshly criticize someone constantly. Is it possible that the best way to criticize someone like Miley (in a culture where validation comes from 'clicks,' shares,' and 'likes') to just ignore her? Taking this route asserts disapproval, but without being outwardly mean or hurtful to her (which could do some serious damage as seen with Britney, Lindsey, etc.)
ReplyDeleteThat said, I also acknowledge that her team deserves some credit for raising sales and marketing her in a way that constantly generates publicity and I agree with what you said about male bodies altering the 'acceptance' of Miley's performances/image.