Thursday, October 24, 2013

Case Explores Rights of Fetus Versus Mother

Alicia Beltran, 14 weeks pregnant, was arrested because of the Cocaine Law which says "child-welfare authorities can forcibly confine a pregnant woman who uses illegal drugs or alcohol “to a severe degree,” and who refuses to accept treatment." In her first prenatal visit with Dr.Breckenridge, Beltran had thought she was doing the right thing giving the doctor her full medical history. This did include drug addiction to pain killers. Months prior to becoming pregnant Beltran had successfully stopped using Perocet and had even stopped using Suboxone, a medicine helped to ease withdrawal symptoms. Numerous clean urine samples confirmed this. 

During the court hearing Dr. Breckenridge claimed Beltran was still using and refused treatment. Thus she was a danger to the unborn child. Dr. Breckenridge recommended Beltran attend a mandatory drug rehabilitation program. 

I became aware of this case because of the New York TImes article. The reader is lead to believe that this is simply malpractice on the part of Dr. Breckenridge. Instead of dissecting the case I found the discussion surrounding Beltran reminiscent of women's historical role in regards to alcohol. (Abortion is also a relevant parallel.) Beltran had a past problem with drugs but does this make her a criminal? 


New York Times Article:
http://www.nytimes.com/2013/10/24/us/case-explores-rights-of-fetus-versus-mother.html?pagewanted=2


The federal challenge can be found
http://advocatesforpregnantwomen.org/blog/2013/10/first_fed_challenge_to_pregnan.php


No comments:

Post a Comment